Gee wrote:Why worry about something you can not change I guess?
Why, indeed!
I feel a bit guilty and selfish because I'm not too sure I
believe in God or another being, but hope there is something so I do carry on existing.
In my opinion (IMO), you are worrying yourself for nothing. If all the NDE accounts I've read are true, a belief in a
god, or lack of, is not a requirement for the afterlife. Regardless what the Abrahamic religions claim,
God is not some jealous and wrathful ego-maniac demanding adoration for all eternity.
Allow me to ask, what do you believe life is? Do you think it is nothing more than an emergent property of the brain due to neuronal activity? Or do you believe it is something more, like a type of energy? IMO, we are energy occupying a body for a purpose. As I've mentioned previously, if our universe is truly holographic in nature, which all the evidence seems to point towards, there is no way possible consciousness can be an emergent property of the brain since our bodies are also part of the holomovement. It is our consciousness which interprets the wave function as objective reality. And for whatever the reason, our consciousness seems to be playing a role in the holoverse. IMO, this implies purpose. While this doesn't necessarily mean there is an afterlife, if we are truly energy rather than physical matter, then continued existence seems to be implied.
fuzoid wrote:Most people wonder about death and are afraid of it. However, the reasons for the fear vary. But if I were to guess, I would believe that it's not so much the fear of death, but rather how one dies.
Gee wrote:Good points. I wonder if I think about death more than the average person?
I can't answer this. And I doubt very seriously if any sociologist ever conducted a statistical analysis regarding this topic. And a psychologist or psychiatrist would probably want to medicate anyone so fixated on death. Suffice to say, since all humans die, all humans think about their mortality. But I would have to believe those with more to lose think about it more often than your average person. But I have no evidence to support this belief.
My advice, stop thinking about death so much. Find a hobby or do something, anything, to keep your mind occupied. Being so fixated on death cannot be a healthy thing.
fuzoid wrote:Try thinking of something else then! In any event, I would not be so concerned about whether or not you're coming back. Because if there is an afterlife and all the NDE accounts are true, you wouldn't want to come back. And if there is no afterlife, then you would never know you're not returning because you would experience nothing!
Gee wrote:Again, good points. In a sense I guess there is nothing to fear, but I hope there is an afterlife rather than it being nothing.
IMO, there is absolutely nothing to fear about death, only how one dies. We would all prefer to slip away during our sleep. Who in their right mind would want to die a horrible pain filled death?
Although I doubt very seriously if I can convince you that there is an afterlife, perhaps the anecdotes of those who have experienced an NDE can? If you haven't already, check out this NDE site:
http://www.near-death.comAnd if this isn't convincing enough for you, check out the site for the International Association for Near Death Studies at
http://www.iands.org. This site is maintained by doctors and scientists who study the NDE and are convinced that the experience is legitimate and offers a glimpse into what awaits us when we die.
Thats a scary thought. To think something I worry about could actually be moulding my future!? I'm going to try and think positive about life and imagine the things I want in life like you have recommended.
There is research which supports negative thinking can have negative consequences. For example, a hypochondriac. Believing they are ill all the time can induce an illness. And if it is true that our consciousness is creating objective reality out of the holographic wave function, then it's quite possible negative thinking can influence how one interprets the wave function, changing it in the process. Think positive thoughts and this is what you will attract to yourself.
Just to let you know though...I am male! When I said I wanted kids, I never meant to physically give birth to them, LOL
Yeah, that's what I get for assuming. LOL!!! Usually when someone says they want to experience children, they are female. To experience implies child birth. And while men also want children, it is probably due to their desire to pass their genetic material on.
fuzoid wrote:Yeah, eternity is an impossible concept to comprehend. And that's because we are creatures who are subject to the space-time of this universe. But in reality, time is relative (in this universe) and does not exist as we understand. So if there is really no past, present, and future, eternity is a little easier to comprehend.
As for what we would do there, well, I guess this depends on each individual! If much of the literature I've read is true, we continue to study and spiritually evolve. But as I understand it, we progress at our own pace. So if you just want to kick back at some lake for an eon or so, then this is your option.
Gee wrote:Its seems some people experience a feeling of all knowing...as if they have all the knowledge they could ever want at their finger tips. If this is the case, then what exactly are we studying if we know everything?
In most every case of an NDEr claiming they have all knowledge, it is usually in the context of our universe, not the afterlife. However, I have read of a few examples of those who gain knowledge of the
void, or rather the
bulk (as understood by physicists) prior to the big bang. Anyway, this is a very good question, what do we continue to study? Well, since this universe is not all there is, it's possible we continue to study what is outside of our universe, the infinite, the potential to create, etc... I suggest you check out a book titled
Journey of Souls for your answers. Although I can't claim this book as factual, it does come the closest to what I believe and makes an awful lot of sense, IMO.
fuzoid wrote:Science has more answers for most people than religion does. And why shouldn't it? But be carerful it does not become your dogma because then you would be less inclined to explore all options, which is really what science is all about! Also bear in mind that science and spiritual matters are not mutually exclusive nor are they incompatible. It is only ones dogma that makes them incompatible.
Gee wrote:I understand. After all, there are plenty of questions science can still no answer.
Correct. And it is questionable if science will ever be able to answer questions pertaining to
God or an afterlife. So when a scientist or atheist claims there is
no God, they are speaking from a position of ignorance based on their dogma. If
God is outside the realm of science, then how can anyone make a factual claim one way or the other? It requires faith. However, science (quantum physics) does seem to point to something more than physical existence (e.g. extra dimensions, holographic universe, quantum entanglement, etc...). Taken with the anecdotal evidence of the NDEr, IMO, it does seem to paint a picture towards continued existence after death.
Not explaining myself very well here. It just seems too much like human, earthly proceedings.
Like doing a crime and going to jail. Do bad things in life and go to hell or come back as a slug.
I don't believe it.
Nor do I. The one thing that seems to be pervasive with the NDE is that the majority who experience it no longer believe in a devil, hell, punishment, eternal damnation, etc. This does not mean that there are not trapped spirits which are interpreted as demons. For example, I have read that so-called ghosts are trapped here by their own volition. Some do not realize they are dead and when a new family moves into their house, they react negatively. There is also anecdotal evidence for a place the Catholics call purgatory. Once again, those who are stuck there are because of their own doing. Some may have been very bad individuals who believe they are not worthy of
God. Or perhaps they are so lost in their addiction of choice that they can't see beyond their self induced hell. But there is no anecdotal evidence of this realm being lorded over by some devil. Nor is there any evidence that it is a form of punishment (other than self induced).
fuzoid wrote:What do you mean by hell? Anyway, most who have an NDE will tell you they saw no evidence for a stereotypical hell, while others will tell you that hell is what we make it. Meaning it is not necessary to die to experience hell since you would be basically creating your own. For example, your fear of dying could be your hell.
Gee wrote:I don't believe in hell. However, I hear stories of eternal burning etc.
The stories are just that, stories. Search the majority of religion's concept of hell and you will soon discover that
Christianity is unique in its view. Not even Judaism or
Islam believe in a hell of fire where a soul is tormented for all eternity. In fact,
Islam believes as the first Christians did, that all return to
God, even the so-called rebellious angels. It's a concept known as Universal Salvation and was prevalent throughout early Christiandom. If I remember correctly, the Eastern Orthodox churches still believe in this concept, especially Russian Orthodoxy. But they do believe someone with negative karma, so to speak, does enter a realm eerily similar to the Catholic purgatory for purification before being allowed into heaven.
The stories of a hell of fire stem from a dump called Gehenna on the outside of ancient Jerusalem. This is where all the trash ended up, including the dead bodies of criminals.
If there is no hell and we all go to a heavenly like place, then what does it matter what bad things we do here if we all go to heaven anyway!?
Good question! And if all the literature I've read is true, it doesn't matter! However, deep inside every one of us is that little spark of
God that tells us right from wrong. What one chooses to do with this knowledge is up to each individual. And since we are all from
God, inherently our soul (for lack of a better term) wants to do what's right. But since there are so many strong temptations for someone to do wrong, our inherent goodness is outvoted. Personally, I believe this is because we forget who we really are. If a murderer knew that they were creating negative karma and would probably have to reincarnate to be murdered, do you believe they would murder? I don't think so.
Anyway, to answer your question, I honestly don't know. But if I was to take a guess, according to much of the literature I've read, every person alive today is exactly where they need to be for this particular life of theirs. Meaning everyone chose the life they are living for whatever the reason and what we view as bad may really have a purpose in the grand scheme of things. However, this is not an invitation to go out and do bad things to others because sooner or later it will come back to haunt you.
fuzoid wrote:Personally, I would say yes, the child would have some concept of
God. Why? Because humans are born believers. For whatever the reason our brains are wired to believe in a
god. Also, since I believe in reincarnation, it is my belief infants still retain a memory of the life between lives. It is only through conditioning do we eventually reject the supernatural.
BTW, I hope all you do is to keep wondering about this because such an experiment would be unethical and illegal.
Gee wrote:I personally think it is due to conditioning that we
believe in God and thoughts of afterlife.
Actually, it is the opposite. Talk to a child from a family with no religious preference and they will gladly answer your questions in the affirmative about a
god. Some will even go into very great detail! It is only through conditioning (or education) do they reject the concept of a
god. However, rejecting the
god concept is not as easy as you would believe because human brains are indeed hardwired to
believe in God. You can read about it here:
http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20126941.700-born-believers-how-your-brain-creates-god.htmlI don't believe that dogs, cat, beetles and slugs know of any type of
God, being or afterlife. Personally I think it would be the same of a child in the scenario I mentioned.
Well, we honestly don't know this to be true. There is some evidence that dogs and cats are psychic in that they can detect if their master is ill, in trouble, etc... So if I had to guess, I would believe they may have some concept of knowing which is inherent in their nature. Meaning they don't question it like humans do. And even if they did, how would we know? LOL!!! But when it comes to insect life, I'm inclined to agree. Insects serve a huge purpose in this life as pollinators or as food for higher species. So IMO insects are nothing more than automatons which serve a specific purpose. But is this belief due to human bias?
Anyway, we will have to agree to disagree on this subject because I believe humans are born with an inherent belief in
God just as we are born with the ability to create and communicate through language.
And of course I would never imagine doing anything like that to a child! I wouldnt do it to a pet, nevermind a human!
I would never believe this of you. It was a rhetorical statement, nothing more.
fuzoid wrote:Well, this is not the standard definition for reincarnation. But your argument does make sense in a weird sort of way. Allow me to ask, what makes you conscious and the matter you would become one with not?
Gee wrote:Well, we are made out of the same matter and particles of everything else in this world. So maybe in some strange way we become part of somebody or something else once we pass.
Perhaps I wasn't clear the first time. So I'll ask the question differently. As you have pointed out, on the particle level, we are all made from the same stuff. So what makes you a living conscious being and a rock not?
I don't or have had any flash backs or thoughts of a previous life if that is what you mean?
No, this is not what I meant. I literally meant, what makes you alive?
Thanks for taking the time to reply and share you thoughts. I was actually waiting and hoping you would reply

You're welcome! And while I greatly appreciate your wanting my response, there are others here that have theories which are just as valid. My only word of caution is, if what someone is telling you contradicts science, then there is something wrong with the theory, not the science.
fuzoid