ddd wrote:Hey fuzoid, my much belated reply. I was tossing up whether to make it or not and it will probably turn into one of my rants but if you've got the ears....
I am torn on this subject, and I'm not just saying that. I wanted to relate a few experiences, one of which is my own. My grandfather you already know about, and these others do not relate to NDE, but they have begun to weigh upon me since this topic cropped up. It's amazing how I had learned not to consider them much at all before.
The first one is most important to me, because it was my own experience. Hate even mentioning it, but I owe you some honesty if we are to discuss these things.
Let me first say, don't ever be ashamed or embarrassed of anything you write or say. Your only true commitment is to yourself and family, no one else. So if someone wants to ridicule, then it is their own ignorance. As for being torn, I completely understand. Even though I know I had a spiritual experience, I had an extremely difficult time accepting it. And I would be lying if I said I no longer question it. Even though it was my reality and I'm alive today because of it, I sometimes have my doubts. Most everyone of faith experiences doubt every once in a while.
Since we're being honest here, one of these days I will post my experience in detail.
When I was in year 8 our phys ed teacher gave us a practice theory test one day. I was going through the questions when I got to 'what leads from the stomach to the small intestine'. When I read it I got that typical dejavu feeling - tightening of the gut, skin prickling etc. Many times I've had dejavu, and I've even recognized having the feeling previously whilst doing the same thing (if that makes any sense). So I fully realize there's nothing magical about it in most cases.
Anyway, I had this feeling, very strong - and I knew a certain girl in the class was going to quiz the teacher on this question. So I turned around (I knew I'd do that too, as if I'd done it before. Everything I did for those few seconds just added to the feeling) and there she was, exactly where I knew she would be - and she asked the question. I realized that I knew how the teacher would reply, and actually mouthed the sentence as she spoke it. And, slacker that I was, I had no right knowing what a duodenum was!
I wrote this off, freak of chance. Perhaps subconsciously remembering the duodenum from a previous lesson etc. Seriously, I've only even thought about it a few times in all the years since. Never had another experience like this one. And I'm skeptical because to believe it, I'd have to believe my mind somehow picked up foreknowledge of something yet to happen.
While I don't claim to know exactly what you experienced, some theories immediately come to mind. In the book
Journey of Souls, there is a very in depth description of the soul choosing their next lifetime. They describe the soul actually viewing their future life so they can either pass on it, or plan it accordingly. If this theory has any reality to it, then it's possible you were recognizing what you had already witnessed. And since this event seems to hold some significance for you, it's possible you were supposed to gain something from it.
The other theory is based on physics and non-linear time. Since time truly does not exist as we understand it, according to theory, it's possible all of past, present and future is occurring now. If the universe is holographic in nature, which I believe it is, then think of it as a film. The entire story is there and you decide to view whichever parts you choose. You can view it from the ending before you even watch the beginning! Or any number of variations! If the universe is holographic, then it's possible the information for the entire history of our universe is embedded within the wavefunction and for whatever the reason, we only experience it as linear time. But all the information is still there and it's quite possible some are able to tap into it. And if there is no such thing as an afterlife or reincarnation, then this theory would also seem to explain people who remember previous lives. Personally, I'm leaning towards both simply due to the empirical evidence.
Mum's cousin's daughter (phew! a friend of a friend of a friend of mine...

) supposedly said to her mother at the breakfast table one morning that one of her aunts was going to die (daughter's great aunt - the plot thickens

) She said it wouldn't be Joan, nor 'oicy' (Loyce) but one of the other two. The call came later that day. Mum told me this, the whole family has heard it, and she's pretty straight up, and I don't see why her cousin would lie about something like that to her own family. Yet some people do I think.
Not to demean the experience, but stories of this nature are more common than you would believe. And I have no problem with it. On the morning of 911 I had a dream that I was a marine in a desert country and I was aiming my rifle at a second floor window so my buddies could safely cross the street. It was so vivid that I woke my wife to tell her about it. It left me with a very bad feeling, only to be confirmed 5 hours later.
And of course we hear about this stuff all the time, the connection between twins, knowing when the phone's about to ring, even some physics (whilst I believe most of it is hit and miss) say things that they have no right to know. And of course NDE's - which in some cases cannot (I fully agree) be written off with a last gasp.
It's ironic that you would mention twins and the NDE in the same breath. When I was studying sociology in college, my professor was an identical twin and I wrote a paper on the NDE. The bulk of the science came from psychologist, Dr. Kenneth Ring, Professor Emeritus at the University of Connecticut. Yes, I said science. Read his book
Life At Death and you'll see what I'm talking about. I also wrote a paper about twins which is how I discovered my professor was one. He confirmed most of what I had researched. Needless to say that I aced both papers.
I believe in evolution, of natural cause and effect.
As do I.
I can perhaps handle that we can connect with each other on occasion, by some slight of physics or whatever the true model of the universe is. Perhaps even seeing a future event is possible, in some way different points in time can be connected.
Which, in my opinion, is a given.
But transcending the body just doesn't fit the picture of life we have thus far teased apart. How could evolution and natural selection come up with this elaborate mechanism.Why, as long as reproduction is achieved?
That's just it, there is no evolutionary benefit to the survival of a species to create an escape mechanism at the moment of death. And the simple fact that much of the anecdotal evidence can be confirmed points to something more than a dream.
And if it is intelligently driven, why bother with all the cause and effect in the first place?
You're second guessing the purpose (if any) for our existence. You're projecting your own beliefs on to a possible creator, which is the same thing the religious do. My advice? Don't worry about it. Just keep living your life and the rest will fall into place, or not.
Also, the old argument - who designed the designer.
Yeah, the ol' skeleton in the closet. The problem with this skeleton is that most who raise the issue are doing so from a religious perspective of who or what
God is supposed to be. The fact is, no matter how strongly anyone believes otherwise, no one knows. And since
God is an unknown entity, it makes no sense to debate who created Him/Her/It/? because you will never have an answer. Either
God exists, or not. It's as simple as that. My advice? Don't worry about it.
Every religion seems to have continuance in common. Death. All through history we've had beliefs of escaping its clutches. And it's so human, an animal instinctively geared for survival and with the cognitive ability to envisage not only death but survival after the fact. I don't blame anyone for their instincts.
Burial evidence seems to point towards Neanderthal and Cromagnum having some sort of religious beliefs as well. So it seems we have a very long history of being believers.
I need to stop here for now. It's getting late and I still haven't eaten my dinner. I'll try to respond to the rest of your message tomorrow.
fuzoid
http://www.live365.com/stations/fuzoid